Yes, Gatekeeper Press is legit. It is a Tampa, Florida self-publishing service that has operated since 2015, holds an A+ BBB rating with two complaints in three years, and passes 100% of net sales proceeds back to its authors. It is not a scam.

The fair question is whether its fees are worth paying, and whether the handful of complaints against it should worry you. Those are different questions from fraud, and they have different answers.

In this check, you’ll learn:

  • What the BBB file, Trustpilot page and both formal complaints actually say
  • Why some Gatekeeper authors got calls claiming the company ā€œis not legitimateā€
  • How the 100% royalty works in dollars, and what it costs to get paid
  • Where Gatekeeper Press does more than we do, and a straight verdict

Here is the evidence, piece by piece.

Is Gatekeeper Press a Scam?

Gatekeeper Press is not a scam. It sells editing, cover design, formatting, ISBNs and distribution for a fee, then delivers a real book listed with real retailers. You keep your rights and your ISBNs, and the company takes no cut of your sales.

The criticism that holds up is about price, not fraud. As of November 2026, its main Signature package costs $3,500, and editing is extra. You can do most of the same work yourself on KDP for a few hundred dollars of freelance help.

That model, where you pay for services up front and keep the royalties, is what separates a paid service from a classic vanity press. Our guide to the difference between a hybrid publisher and a vanity press explains why that line matters.

For the full package breakdown, editing math and terms, read our Gatekeeper Press review. This page sticks to one question: can you trust the company?

Who Runs Gatekeeper Press?

Gatekeeper Press was founded in 2015 by Rob Price, a self-published author who was treasurer of the Independent Book Publishers Association at the time, according to Publishers Weekly’s launch coverage.

From the start, the pitch was the same one it uses today: authors pay for services, set their own prices, keep all print and digital rights, and receive a 100% royalty. The PW piece also notes each author gets a US-based Author Manager.

The company is registered as Gatekeeper Press LLC in Tampa. Its BBB profile lists a business start date of May 27, 2015, which matches the launch coverage.

It is independent. Gatekeeper is not one of the Author Solutions imprints such as AuthorHouse, Xlibris and iUniverse, whose shared reputation we cover in our Author Solutions review.

What Does the Gatekeeper Press BBB Rating Show?

Gatekeeper Press has an A+ BBB rating and has been BBB-accredited since December 22, 2023. As of November 12, 2026, its Better Business Bureau profile showed:

BBB metricGatekeeper Press LLC
RatingA+
Accredited sinceDecember 22, 2023
Business startedMay 27, 2015
Complaints, last 3 years2
Complaints, last 12 months0
Customer reviews118, averaging 4.96 stars

Read the A+ with care. A BBB grade mostly reflects complaint handling, transparency and time in business. The BBB states that customer reviews do not count toward the rating.

Two complaints in three years is a very low count for a company that says it has served more than 4,000 authors. For contrast, the shared Author Solutions profile showed 70 complaints in three years when we checked it for our Xlibris legitimacy check.

What Do Gatekeeper Press Complaints Say?

There are two formal Gatekeeper Press complaints on the BBB, both from 2024, and neither involves a book that was paid for and never produced. Here is what each one says, from the BBB complaints page:

  1. Billing, November 2024 (resolved). An author who had received royalties fee-free for two years objected to a new $1.05 ACH deposit fee. Gatekeeper said it had absorbed the fee before and now passes it on, and offered ways to reduce it. The author accepted the response.
  2. Service, April 2024 (answered, not accepted). An author who paid $2,500 reported missing and misprinted author copies and quality problems in sold books. The author said a $750 refund offer was tied to signing a nondisclosure agreement.

Gatekeeper’s public reply to the second complaint says the author was abusive to staff and threatened to disparage the company to get a refund. It says it ended the relationship and called the complaint false. The author rejected that response.

We cannot verify either side. What we can say is that the dispute is about one author’s service and refund, and the company answered it in public.

Gatekeeper Press reviews complaints on Trustpilot

Gatekeeper Press has a 3.9 TrustScore on Trustpilot from only 7 reviews, as of November 12, 2026: 71% five-star and 29% one-star. Trustpilot notes the company has not recently invited reviews, so the sample is small.

The one detailed negative review on its Trustpilot page, posted December 2025, alleges about $600 in unpaid royalties, an unpaid $750 refund for ebook formatting, a missed deadline and a payment offer conditioned on an NDA.

Gatekeeper’s reply, six days later, says the author broke its Author Code of Conduct, lost chargeback disputes and kept harassing staff. The $750 refund and the NDA match the April 2024 BBB complaint, so this looks like the same dispute appearing twice rather than a pattern. That is our inference, not a confirmed fact.

The Code of Conduct is real. Gatekeeper’s terms of service say you agree not to use ā€œabusive, harmful, or offensive languageā€ and that it can end the relationship if you do.

Why Do People Say Gatekeeper Press Is a Scam?

Most ā€œGatekeeper Press scamā€ talk traces back to a phone scam aimed at its authors, not to the company itself. In August 2025, Gatekeeper published a warning about publishing scams after several authors got near-identical voicemails.

The caller, using the name ā€œAttorney Ben Clark,ā€ claimed Gatekeeper was not legitimate, said the author’s book ā€œwas reported,ā€ and pushed for a callback. Gatekeeper calls these claims false and suggests the goal is phishing or poaching authors for a rival service.

Its advice is sound for any author: do not engage, forward the message to your Author Manager, block the number, and report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. Note that this account comes from Gatekeeper itself.

The same pattern hits authors at many companies. Unsolicited calls about film deals, legal problems or ā€œreportedā€ books are a classic tactic, and our list of vanity press warning signs covers how to spot them.

What independent watchdogs say

Author watchdogs have not flagged Gatekeeper Press. The Alliance of Independent Authors lists it as ā€œALLi Recommendedā€ on its 2026 sponsors page, where it is also a Silver Sponsor. A paid sponsorship is worth knowing when you weigh that label.

Our searches found no Writer Beware post about Gatekeeper Press, no class action and no Reddit threads with real volume. That absence matters: the predatory services on author watchdog lists usually leave a long, public trail.

How Do Gatekeeper Press Royalties Work?

Gatekeeper Press pays you 100% of net proceeds, meaning what is left after the retailer’s discount and the printing cost. It does not mean 100% of the cover price. The company keeps nothing per sale and adds no markup to printing.

The Gatekeeper royalty formula for print is retail price Ɨ (1 āˆ’ (wholesale discount + Ingram market access fee)) āˆ’ printing cost. You choose a 40% discount for online retailers or 53% for bookstore placement, and Ingram takes 1.85% of retail on its sales.

Here is our illustration, not a Gatekeeper figure: a $16.99 paperback with an assumed $4.50 print cost.

Sales channelRoyalty per copyCopies to recover $3,500
Amazon direct (40%)about $5.69about 615
Online via Ingram (40% + 1.85%)about $5.38about 651
Bookstores (53% + 1.85%)about $3.17about 1,104

That is roughly what you would earn publishing the same book yourself, and several times what a 10% royalty pays at the Author Solutions imprints. Our explainer on how book royalties work shows how these rates compare across the industry.

How long does Gatekeeper Press take to pay?

Gatekeeper Press pays royalties monthly, about 90 days after the end of the sales month, per its payment help page. Amazon KDP pays its own authors about 60 days after month end.

A third-party processor also deducts a fee from each payment, which Gatekeeper says it does not profit from. As of November 2026 the help page lists:

  • Direct deposit (US): $1.05 per payment
  • PayPal (US): $1.05 plus 2%, capped at $2.10
  • Check (US): $2.09
  • Wire (US): $15.75

You set your own payout threshold, with a $10 minimum. Raising it means fewer payments and fewer fees, which is the fix Gatekeeper offered in the 2024 billing complaint.

What Does Gatekeeper Press Cost?

Gatekeeper Press costs $3,500 for its Signature package as of November 2026, or $3,250 with its $499-a-year Gatekeeper+ membership, according to its pricing page. The Poetry/Novella package is $4,000 and the Children’s Book package is $3,500.

Editing is extra on the Signature package: $25 per 1,000 words for proofreading, $35 for copy editing plus proofreading, and $55 with a developmental edit. A copy-edited 70,000-word book therefore runs about $5,950 in total.

The pricing page shows higher struck-through prices next to each package, so expect discount framing. Our Gatekeeper Press review has the complete table, every add-on, and what the membership actually saves.

Gatekeeper Press Red Flags to Check Before You Pay

None of these points make Gatekeeper a scam. They are the places where authors most often feel surprised, so get answers in writing first.

  • No general refund policy is published. The terms offer a satisfaction guarantee on file creation, excluding editing and marketing, but no refund schedule for package fees. Both complaints above turned on a refund.
  • Changes after approval cost money. Pre-publication change batches start at $40, post-publication batches at $80, and reformatting after layout approval is $125 an hour.
  • Your book sits in Gatekeeper’s accounts. Moving it to your own KDP account is free before publication but costs $150 afterward, per the pricing page.
  • The membership auto-renews. Gatekeeper+ bills $499 a year until you cancel.
  • Payment fees are passed on. Each royalty payment carries a processing fee, small but real if you get paid often.

If a company pressures you to pay before you see these details, that is a warning sign anywhere. Gatekeeper publishes most of them openly, which is a point in its favor.

Where Gatekeeper Press Does More Than We Do

We make Chapter, so here is a straight list of what Gatekeeper Press does that our writing software does not.

It publishes your book. Gatekeeper formats the interior, designs the cover, assigns ISBNs and lists the book with Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Google Play and Ingram, with no annual distribution fee. Chapter’s writing software produces a manuscript and stops there.

It edits with people. Gatekeeper’s proofreaders, copy editors and developmental editors are humans with published per-word rates. Chapter drafts in your voice, but it is not a professional human editor.

It gives you a person to call. The most consistent praise in its BBB reviews is for named Author Managers who guide first-time authors. Chapter is software you drive yourself.

It prints physical proofs and author copies. You hold a printed book before release. Our software does not print anything.

On rights and money, the two match: both leave you with 100% of your rights and royalties.

Is Gatekeeper Press Worth It?

Gatekeeper Press is worth it for a specific author: your manuscript is finished, you want professionals to handle editing and production, and you can spend $3,500 to $8,000 without needing the book to earn it back quickly.

It is a poor fit if you are on a tight budget or plan to publish often. Amazon KDP costs nothing to set up and pays the same net royalty directly, and our guide to self-publishing a book for free shows the route step by step.

Our breakdown of the cost to self-publish a book shows what a few hundred dollars of freelance editing and design buys. If you are comparing other paid services, our BookBaby legitimacy check and AuthorHouse legitimacy check apply the same tests.

The Verdict and the Alternative We Built

Gatekeeper Press is a legitimate, author-friendly paid service. You keep your rights, ISBNs and net royalties, the prices are public, and the complaint record is thin and disputed. You will pay well for convenience, though, and you could do the same work yourself for far less.

Many authors pricing out a Gatekeeper package hit an earlier wall: the manuscript is not finished. No publishing package helps until the book exists.

Our Pick — Chapter

Chapter is AI book writing software that takes you from an idea to a complete, structured manuscript in your voice. More than 10,000 authors have used it, and it has been featured in USA Today and the New York Times. You keep 100% of the rights and publish wherever you choose.

Best for: Authors who have the idea but not the finished manuscript Pricing: $97 one time, 2 books included (fiction or nonfiction), 30-day money-back guarantee Why we built it: A $3,500 publishing package is worth nothing until the book is written, and writing is where most authors stall.

Chapter has honest limits. There is no free tier or trial, it is not a human editor, and the writing software does not print or distribute your book. You still review and revise what it drafts. Our Chapter review covers it in full.

If your book is already written and you want it produced for less than a per-book package, Chapter’s Publishing AI costs $997 a year for unlimited books as of November 2026. It uses AI editing rather than a human editor, and Chapter is not the publisher of record, so weigh that against Gatekeeper’s people.

If your book is still unwritten, Chapter for nonfiction and Chapter for fiction write the complete manuscript for $97 one time, with no subscription and a 30-day money-back guarantee, before you spend anything on publishing.

FAQ

Is Gatekeeper Press legit?

Yes, Gatekeeper Press is legit. It is a Tampa self-publishing service founded in 2015, with an A+ BBB rating, two complaints in three years and an ā€œALLi Recommendedā€ listing. You keep your rights, ISBNs and 100% of net royalties. The fair criticism is cost, not fraud.

Is Gatekeeper Press a scam?

Gatekeeper Press is not a scam. Authors who pay receive real, distributed books, and the company publishes its prices. Most ā€œscamā€ claims trace to impersonation calls from a fake attorney telling its authors the company was not legitimate, which Gatekeeper publicly warned authors about in August 2025.

What are the main Gatekeeper Press complaints?

The main Gatekeeper Press complaints are a 2024 BBB complaint about a new $1.05 ACH payment fee, since resolved, and one author’s dispute over author copies, a refund and an NDA, which appears on both the BBB and Trustpilot. Gatekeeper disputes that account, and we could not verify either side.

Does Gatekeeper Press really pay 100% royalties?

Yes, Gatekeeper Press pays 100% of net proceeds, meaning what remains after the retailer’s discount and the printing cost, not 100% of the cover price. Payments arrive about 90 days after the sales month, minus a small processing fee charged by its payment provider.

What is the Gatekeeper Press BBB rating?

The Gatekeeper Press BBB rating is A+, with BBB accreditation since December 22, 2023. As of November 2026 the profile showed 2 complaints in three years, none in the last 12 months, and 118 customer reviews averaging 4.96 stars. BBB grades reflect complaint handling, not customer satisfaction.