Yes, Pegasus Publishers is legit in the legal sense. Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie Publishers Ltd is a registered, active UK company in Cambridge that has published books since 1999, and authors who sign with it get real, printed books. It does not take your money and vanish.

The harder question is whether you should pay it. Many authors who get a Pegasus offer are asked for a “contribution” of a few thousand pounds, and every independent watchdog that has looked at the company classes that model as vanity publishing.

In this assessment, you’ll learn:

  • What the Companies House record, Trustpilot score and BBB situation actually show
  • What Pegasus charges, and what the UK Society of Authors found when it investigated the company
  • How many copies you would need to sell to earn back a typical fee
  • Where Pegasus genuinely does more than we do, and a straight verdict

If you are comparing it with its closest relative, our Austin Macauley legitimacy check applies the same tests. This page answers one question: can you trust Pegasus?

Is Pegasus Publishers a Scam?

Pegasus Publishers is not a scam. It edits, designs, prints and distributes real books under its own imprints, and it lists them with UK trade databases. The fair criticism is about value and transparency, not fraud: authors on its shared-cost contracts pay toward publication and rarely earn that money back.

Three facts support the “not a scam” verdict:

  • It is a registered company. Companies House lists Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie Publishers Limited (company 04256271) as active, incorporated in July 2001, with book publishing as its business. It filed accounts to August 2025 and a confirmation statement in July 2026.
  • It has a long publishing record. Its own history page dates the business to 1999 and says it reached its first 100 published books in 2002. On Trustpilot it describes a catalog of more than 2,000 titles.
  • It runs real imprints. Vanguard Press publishes fiction and nonfiction, Nightingale Books publishes children’s titles, and Chimera publishes adult fiction.

So the honest answer to “is Pegasus Publishers a scam” is no. The honest answer to “is it a good deal” depends on which contract you are offered, and most evidence points to the paid one.

Who Runs Pegasus Publishers?

Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie Publishers Ltd runs Pegasus Publishers, trading from Sheraton House, Castle Park, Cambridge, with a registered office in Ely, Cambridgeshire. It shares history and people with Austin Macauley, the paid publisher named most often in the Society of Authors’ 2022 survey.

The Companies House officer list shows officers named Bedar as directors or secretaries from 2001 to 2018. Bu-Azal Bedar has been a person with significant control since 2018, and Mohamed Ben Malik has been the sole active director since February 2018.

Writer Beware reports that Bu-Azal Bedar was company secretary at Austin Macauley from 2007 to 2012. It also says the two companies’ author contracts are word-for-word identical, with a few exceptions.

That link matters. If you have read complaints about Austin Macauley’s contracts, assume the same questions apply here until you see your own contract. Our Austin Macauley review covers those terms in detail.

Is Pegasus Publishers the same as Pegasus Books?

No. Pegasus Publishers is not Pegasus Books. Three unrelated companies share the name, and searches mix them up:

CompanyWhereWhat it is
Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie (Pegasus Publishers)Cambridge, UKThe subject of this page: traditional and shared-cost contracts
Pegasus BooksNew York, USAn independent trade publisher founded in 2006, distributed by Simon & Schuster
Pegasus Books of CaliforniaCalifornia, USA small press that drew serious author complaints in 2016

If someone tells you “Pegasus” is a scam, check which one they mean. Most Reddit and forum threads about fees concern the Cambridge company.

How Much Does Pegasus Publishers Charge?

Pegasus Publishers does not publish its fees. Its About page now says it offers two contract types. Under a traditional contract the publisher covers the costs, and under a shared-cost contract “the author contributes towards the cost of publication.”

What authors actually report paying comes from watchdogs:

  • Around ÂŁ2,500 on average. Writer Beware says fees reported to it average about ÂŁ2,500, with the highest reported at ÂŁ4,500.
  • The fee is labeled an “Advance.” In a normal deal the publisher pays the author an advance. In the Pegasus contract Writer Beware reviewed, the “Advance” runs the other way: you pay it.
  • Terms vary. The About page says contract terms may vary by manuscript, format, imprint and contract type, so two authors can get different quotes.

Pegasus does not publish its royalty rates either. Ask for the rate on every format, and whether it is calculated on list price or net receipts, before you sign anything.

Does Pegasus offer traditional contracts?

Pegasus says it offers traditional contracts, where it pays all costs and you pay nothing. We could not find any published figure for how many authors receive one versus a shared-cost offer.

If you get a traditional offer, treat it like any small-press deal: check the rights grant, the term, the royalty basis and how rights revert. If you get a shared-cost offer, read on.

What Did the Society of Authors Find About Pegasus?

The UK Society of Authors named Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie in its 2022 investigation into paid-for publishing. Pegasus was mentioned by 11 survey respondents, tied for second most, behind Austin Macauley’s 34.

The report, Is it a steal?, was published by the Society of Authors and the Writers’ Guild of Great Britain. It surveyed 240 writers in early 2021, then reviewed how the most-named companies market themselves.

Its findings on Pegasus, from an October 2021 review:

  • Ads ranked above organic results for searches such as “children’s publishers” and “crime publishers.”
  • No mention of fees appeared in the ads, the landing pages, the submission pages or the terms and conditions.
  • “Traditional and inclusive contracts” were mentioned with no explanation of what “inclusive” meant.
  • The report concluded that writers could not make an informed decision at the point of submission.

Pegasus has since added a plain explanation of shared-cost contracts to its About page, which is a real improvement. It still does not show what the contribution costs.

Across all paid-for publishers, not Pegasus alone, the report found:

FindingFigure
Median cost to the writerÂŁ2,000
Median copies sold per deal67
Median royalties earnedÂŁ68
Median loss per dealÂŁ1,861
Writers who lost money94%
Writers whose book was not in retail outlets59%

What Do Pegasus Publishers Reviews Say?

Pegasus Publishers reviews on Trustpilot are split. As of November 13, 2026, its Trustpilot profile showed a TrustScore of 3.8 from 166 reviews: 53% five-star and 26% one-star, with little in between.

The rest of the breakdown was 12% four-star, 4% three-star and 5% two-star. Pegasus claimed the profile in March 2024, invites customers to leave reviews, and replies to every negative review.

The positive reviews consistently praise:

  • Kind, supportive staff, often named individually
  • Clear guidance from manuscript to finished book
  • Careful editing, formatting and cover design
  • Flexibility on changes and deadline extensions

The negative reviews we could see cluster around:

  • Long delays, with one reviewer describing a wait of more than two years
  • Unanswered questions and slow communication
  • Editing quality, including continuity errors the author had to fix
  • A request to cancel the contract after months without progress

Both sets are real experiences. The pattern resembles other paid publishers: people who wanted a smooth, supported process are often happy, while people who expected a traditional publisher’s sales effort are not.

What Is the Pegasus Publishers BBB Rating?

Pegasus Publishers has no BBB rating. The Better Business Bureau covers businesses in the US, Canada and Mexico, and we found no BBB profile for Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie, a UK company. A BBB listing named “Pegasus Publishing” belongs to an unrelated Texas business.

The closest equivalent for a UK author service is the Alliance of Independent Authors (ALLi) Watchdog Desk. Its service ratings list Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie Publishers as “Caution,” with concerns about value, service, marketing and practices, as of November 2026.

ALLi rates on pricing, service quality, contract terms, transparency and customer satisfaction. A “Caution” rating is not a fraud finding. It means the watchdog advises you to look hard before you pay.

Is There a Pegasus Publishers Lawsuit?

We found no lawsuit, court judgment or regulatory action against Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie in the public sources we searched, including UK and US news coverage and author watchdog sites, as of November 2026.

The complaints against Pegasus are about value, transparency and service, not illegal conduct. Those are contract disputes you would handle yourself, which makes the contract you sign the most important document in the process.

How Many Books Would You Need to Sell?

To earn back a typical Pegasus contribution, you would need to sell well over a thousand copies. Pegasus does not publish its royalty rates, so the table below uses illustrative per-copy earnings, not Pegasus figures, against Writer Beware’s reported average fee of £2,500.

Your earnings per copy (illustration)Copies to earn back ÂŁ2,500
ÂŁ1.002,500
ÂŁ2.001,250
ÂŁ3.00About 834

The Society of Authors found a median of 67 copies sold per paid-for deal. At almost any realistic royalty, most authors on a shared-cost contract will not recover their contribution.

Compare that with publishing yourself. On Amazon KDP, a paperback priced at ÂŁ7.99 or more on Amazon.co.uk, or $9.99 on Amazon.com, earns 60% of list price minus printing costs, and you pay nothing up front. Our explainer on how book royalties work shows typical rates by format.

Pegasus Publishers Red Flags to Check Before You Sign

These are the questions to answer in writing before you sign with Pegasus, or with any publisher that asks you to pay.

  • What exactly does the contribution buy? Ask for an itemized breakdown of the fee against editing, design, printing and marketing costs.
  • How long does the rights grant last? Writer Beware reports that the near-identical Austin Macauley contract has no stated term, with reversion at the publisher’s discretion.
  • What is the royalty basis? A percentage of list price is worth far more than a percentage of net receipts.
  • What marketing is guaranteed? The publicity described on Pegasus’s process page happens “where appropriate,” which is not a commitment.
  • How do you leave? Find the cancellation and refund terms, especially if production stalls.

The Authors Guild guidance on hybrid publishing contracts recommends asking whether other authors have earned back their fees. Our checklist of vanity press warning signs and our guide to the difference between a hybrid publisher and a vanity press apply the same tests.

Where Pegasus Publishers Does More Than We Do

We make Chapter, so here is a straight list of what Pegasus does that we do not.

It gives you a publisher’s imprint. Your book carries Vanguard Press, Nightingale Books or Chimera on the spine. Chapter does not put its name on your book or give you an imprint.

It has its own warehouse. Pegasus says it runs an in-house warehouse and distribution centre, and it lists books with UK trade databases including Nielsen and Gardners. Chapter does not store or ship stock.

It gives you people. A production coordinator, a design team and a publicist guide you through each stage. If you want a human team, that has real value.

It sends you copies. Authors receive complimentary copies after publication. Chapter produces files and listings, not boxes of books.

It may offer a traditional contract. If your manuscript earns one, Pegasus pays the costs. Chapter is a tool you pay for, never a publishing deal.

Is Pegasus Publishers Worth It?

Pegasus Publishers is worth it only in a narrow case: you have a finished manuscript, you are offered a traditional contract with no fee, or you can comfortably spend a few thousand pounds for a guided service and a UK imprint without expecting to earn it back.

It is a poor fit if you want your book to pay for itself. A median of 67 copies sold will not recover a ÂŁ2,500 contribution at any realistic royalty.

If you want a traditional deal, an agent is the usual route, and our guides on how to find a literary agent and how to write a query letter cover it. If you want control, Amazon KDP and IngramSpark let you publish yourself, and our breakdown of the cost to self-publish a book shows where a few hundred pounds of freelance help goes furthest.

The Verdict and the Alternative We Built

Pegasus Publishers is a legitimate company with a long record and real books. Its shared-cost contracts, though, follow the vanity model watchdogs warn about: you pay up front, the fee is not published, and the evidence says most authors lose money.

If your manuscript is finished and you want it published without handing over rights or paying per book, there is a cheaper route.

Our Pick — Chapter Publishing AI

Chapter Publishing AI takes a finished manuscript to Amazon and beyond. It handles AI editing and proofreading, a full print-wrap cover, paperback, hardcover and Kindle editions with 3 ISBNs per book in your name, keywords, categories and your Amazon listing, then distribution to 45,000+ stores and libraries. You keep 100% of your rights and royalties.

Best for: Authors with a finished manuscript who were about to pay a contribution fee Pricing: $997 a year for unlimited books, as of November 2026 Why we built it: Getting a finished book published should not cost thousands of pounds per title.

It has real limits. Chapter is not your publisher of record, no human editor reads your book, and you publish from your own Amazon account with a guided walkthrough. There is no imprint, warehouse or publicist, so Pegasus offers more hand-holding.

If your book is still unwritten, Chapter for nonfiction and Chapter for fiction write the complete manuscript for $97 one time, with 2 books included, no subscription and a 30-day money-back guarantee. More than 10,000 authors have used it, and our Chapter review covers what it does not do.

FAQ

Is Pegasus Publishers a legitimate publisher?

Pegasus Publishers is a legitimate company. Pegasus Elliot Mackenzie Publishers Ltd is an active UK company registered since 2001, publishing since 1999, and it produces real books. Watchdogs class its shared-cost contracts as vanity publishing, because many authors pay a contribution toward costs.

Is Pegasus Publishers a scam?

Pegasus Publishers is not a scam. Authors who sign receive edited, designed and printed books under its imprints. The criticism is about value and transparency: fees averaging about £2,500 reported to Writer Beware, unpublished prices and royalty rates, and a “Caution” rating from the Alliance of Independent Authors.

How much does Pegasus Publishers charge authors?

Pegasus Publishers does not publish its fees. Writer Beware reports author contributions averaging about ÂŁ2,500, with the highest reported at ÂŁ4,500. Pegasus says authors on traditional contracts pay nothing, while those on shared-cost contracts contribute toward publication costs.

Is Pegasus Publishers the same company as Austin Macauley?

Pegasus Publishers and Austin Macauley are separate companies with shared history. Writer Beware reports that their author contracts are nearly word-for-word identical and that a current Pegasus shareholder was company secretary at Austin Macauley from 2007 to 2012. Both are classed by watchdogs as paid-for publishers.

What are the most common Pegasus Publishers complaints?

The most common Pegasus Publishers complaints concern long publication delays, slow or unanswered communication, editing quality and contract cancellations. Watchdogs add a lack of fee transparency. Trustpilot showed a 3.8 TrustScore from 166 reviews in November 2026, split between five-star and one-star ratings.